Masky X Reader - No Sweets For You

A/N: Hey guys~! Well I meant to have this up on Halloween but didn't even get to start it, so it's late. :I But oh well, I'm writing it anyway. And this is my first CreepyPasta X Reader~! Yays~! :3 Now I would suggest you guys listen to 'It Went' by S3RL before reading this, and just so you guys know I put Shiloh in here and I paired her up with Lost Silver cause I ship them together. I'll give explanations for that sometime but for now enjoy this Masky X Reader~!

~~~~~~~~~~

Knock! Knock! Knock!

. . . . . . . . .

Knock! Knock! Knock!

. . . . . . . . .

You sighed before stomping your foot once in a little tantrum.

"Guys! Let me in!" You yelled at the door to the CP base. After a second you heard rustling like someone fell off the couch and then the many locks being un-locked. The door opened to show you the white and black mask of Masky.

"Oh! S-Sorry _____. We didn't think you'd be back so early." He said as he backed up, letting you in.

"It's fine Mask. But if I'm gonna be bringing groceries for you guys all the time, you gotta leave the door unlocked. At least whenever I say I'm going shopping." You said, sitting down the many plastic bags hanging on your arms onto the kitchen counter. Masky walked over and helped you start putting away the groceries.

"Slenderman won't allow it. You know how dangerous it is right now." He said, placing some cereal in the cabinet.

"Yeah I know, I know."

Recently the police have been more on the lookout, more people becoming suspicious of the CPs. But it couldn't be helped. If you put your Creepy life-story online, people are bound to read it. It had gotten so bad recently that no one could even go out of the base unless to kill. So, since Masky happened to go to your school awhile back, meaning you two had become close friends in fact so close that he told you about all the CPs, you were asked to get things for them. You couldn't say no to your Masky-baby, he always finds ways to convince you anyways, usually using his *cough*adorable*cough* puppy face. So pretty much now you bring groceries to the CP base every week or whenever something was needed.

 "Masky-baby, can you get the rest? I'm really tired today, the police were everywhere. And that doesn't make it easy for me to sneak around, not to mention while carrying a lot of bangs on my arms." You asked, turning toward the living room anyways.

"Yeah, sure _____." Masky continued with the groceries as you flopped on the couch, letting your legs fall on Jeff's in the process.

"Hey!" Jeff said angrily.

"Whaaaaaaaaaat?" You asked, obviously tired. Jeff looked over at you, stared for a sec, then grumbled something to himself before turning back to the TV. You looked at the TV too, to notice it was showing BEN's current game of COD (Call Of Duty). BEN turned and said 'Hi _____' then went back to his video game.

You watched him play for awhile but then he got bored and turned the TV off. Well it was more of Ben got beat a million times and threw the controller onto the power button, but whatever.

"Rage quitter." Jeff said with a snicker.

"I am NOT a rage quitter. I'm just going to lay down for awhile." And then BEN proceeded to lay back with his arms under his head and his eyes closed.

Masky then walked in, about to ask you something, but then decided to lift your head and sit down on the couch, placing your head on his lap. You nuzzled into his leg like a pillow and he started to play with your hair. After awhile you could tell the other two guys were becoming bored, so you, also somewhat bored, decided to sing the first song that came to mind just because. Well you sing all the time anyways, and you could tell all the guys liked it when you sang.

"Last night I went raving. Raving, raving.

All night techno playing. Playing, playing.

One song that I heard played. Heard played, heard played.

In my mind it has stayed. Has stayed, has stayed.

I have no clue to the track name~

It's driving me insane~

The tune plays through my head~

And this is how it weeeeeennnnnnttt~

It went:

Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~"

All the guys closed their eyes and waved their heads to the rhythm of the song, Masky humming along. You also closed your eyes as you sung.

"It went:

Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~"

Jeff decided to join in by taking the part of the guy who always says 'Like this'.

"LIKE THIS~!:" You giggled as he fist pumped the air and then continued, all the guys joining in as the background singers.

"Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~"

"It went:

Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~"

"LIKE THIS~!" BEN said it this time, also fist pumping the air.

Then you all played out the beat on random objects like the couch and floor.

"La La Laa la~

The tune plays through my head,

and this is how it went."

"LIKE THIS~!" Masky this time. By now Jack, Hoodie, Slendy, Shiloh Stitchwork, and Jane had all come into the room and sang along as more background singers, Shiloh and Jane singing your lines along with you. Smile had also come in but couldn't sing since he was a dog.

"LIKE THIS~!" Hoodie this time.

"Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!"

"It went:

Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!"

"LIKE THIS~!" Jack this time.

"Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!"

"It went:

Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!"

"LIKE THIS~!"  Guess who~ Slendy this time!

"LIKE THIS~!" Shiloh did it this time in her now goofy mood. Then her and Jane let you do the next lines by yourself.

"Last night I went raving. Raving, raving.

All night techno playing. Playing, playing.

One song that I heard played. Heard played, heard played.

In my mind it has stayed. Has stayed, has stayed.

I have no clue to the track name~

It's driving me insane~

The tune plays through my head~

And this is how it went~" Everyone joins in again.

"Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!"

"It went:

Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!"

"LIKE THIS~!" Jeff again.

"Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!"

"It went:

Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!" Now yourself.

"La La Laa La~

La La Laa La~"

"LIKE THIS~!" BEN again.

"La La Laa La~

La La Laa La~"

"LIKE THIS~!" Mask again.

"Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!"

"It went:

Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!"

"LIKE THIS~!" Jack again.

"Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~!"

"It went:

Do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do,

do de do de do~"

And then the song ended, making everyone laugh after having a good time. Even if they were on lockdown they could still have fun with simple stuff like singing. Everyone eventually walked off to who know where, leaving you alone with Masky, Jeff, and BEN again. Masky decided to finally ask his question.

"So _____, why'd you get candy at the store?" BEN immediately sat up with wide eyes.

"CANDY?!" And he ran off into the kitchen, Shiloh following after hearing their was candy in the house/base. Jeff would've followed too if not for your legs laying on his.

"Cause I thought it would be nice. It is Halloween soon ya know Mask." You said, looking up at him before sitting up, releasing Jeff to go get some candy, and stretching your arms.

"Well I guess. Too bad the police are all on guard, we can't really go get our own candy this year." Masky said.

"There's my point~!" You said, poking his chest once.

"Ow! What was that for?" He asked, apparently you hit him a little too hard.

"I dunno." You said. You noticed his arms move and then you tried to run, but were held down on the couch.

"NUUUUUU! DON'T MASK!" You yelled for help, knowing what was coming.

"Too late for that _____~" And then he started at the waist, tickling the crap outta you. It went on for awhile before you ended up being unable to breath anymore, so he stopped for now and sat you up, putting his arm around your shoulder. You began to regain your breath and after a moment spoke.

"Oh yeah, Mask?"

"Hmm?"

"You don't get any of the candy."

"What?! Why?!" He asked surprised. All CPs like candy, and Mask especially liked sweets.

"Because~"

"Not a valid reason _____."

"Because I said so Mask. You'll know why eventually~"

He made a pout face behind his mask, you were only able to tell because it raised a bit as he puffed out his cheeks and he crossed his arms. But he decided to go along with it.

~~~~~((TIMESKIP~! BROUGHT TO YOU BY SINGING SLENDY~!))~~~~~

Halloween eventually came, and still the CPs couldn't go out. The police were on extra guard tonight, knowing they could be mixed in with the trick-or-treaters, but they weren't. So you being the nice person you are, and awesome baker you are, you decided to bake the CPs some Halloween cupcakes. You had them with Orange, white, yellow, black, and red icing, and of course sprinkles. Half white, half chocolate since you didn't know who liked what. You put on your yellow hoodie that Mask had given you, and told your parents 'Bye' as you took the cupcakes and left. Now to get past all the police, trick-or-treaters, and get through the forest with a box of cupcakes. Can't be that hard right?

~~~~~(( MINI TIMESKIP BROUGHT TO YOU BY SHILOH'S GOOFY MOOD~!!))~~~~~

Well. You made it into the forest finally. You almost got pulled out from the crowd by a cop, when you managed to slip through and into the forest. And luckily none of the kids asked for your cupcakes. At least except one, which was so cute in her little costume you had to give her one, making sure to tell her mom to watch ad make sure she doesn't ruin her outfit. Good thing you made a lot of extra cupcakes.

You eventually got to the base and kicked the door, signaling that you wanted in. Your hands were too full with your box of cupcakes. Slender opened the door, ready to kill a policeman until he saw it was you, and backed up to let you in. Which you did, then sat the cupcakes down on the table in the kitchen. The box was plain white so no one could see inside.

"Slendy you get first choice." You said, opening the box showing Slenderman what was inside. He bent over you, considering how tall he was, and looked over them. He didn't really care that you called him Slendy, since he kinda ignored it. Plus you were like the only human not afraid of him.

He reached over and took one plain cupcake with black icing, patting your head with his free hand. He told you thanks and went back to his office, passing Shiloh and Lost Silver in the hallway. Shiloh stopped him.

"Slendy! Where did you get that?!" She asked, pointing at his cupcake, drooling the tiniest bit.

"_____ brought them." He said before walking off.

"_____'S CUPCAKES?! I WANT ONE!" Shiloh said, alerting almost all other CPs since they opened their doors at her outburst. Shiloh wanted first dibs so she started pushing Lost Silver down the hall and toward the kitchen, she did love cupcakes but wouldn't leave her boyfriend behind. She burst into the kitchen where you were placing the cupcakes on small plates you had brought, Lost Silver following slowly.

"_____ you brought cupcakes!" Shiloh said, running up to you looking over the delicious sweets. You looked at her with a smile, putting a cupcake on a plate.

"Yeah I did. You want one?" You said, holding the plate out to her, which she greedily took.

"YES~!" Shiloh happily ate the cupcake, walking over to Lost Silver.

"You want one Silver?" You asked him. He looked up at you and shook his head.

"No thanks _____." He said softly, floating after Shiloh to the living room as others piled in the kitchen.

BEN and Jeff practically pushing each other around, making you giggle before giving them both a cupcake. You gave everyone a cupcake until your boyfriend Mask was left, who had waited and helped you give out cupcakes.

"Now remember, no cupcake for you Mask~" You said, eating the last one. He pouted again, crossing his arms.

"How come you keep telling me not to eat anything you bring?!" He said angerly.

"You can eat regular food." You said with a poker face.

"But why can't I eat sweets?! We're supposed to be dating but your keeping me from sweets, and on Halloween too! You know I have a sweet tooth like Shiloh!"

"I know. Don't worry Masky Baby~ I've got something special for you~! I just had to make it, but couldn't bring it and the cupcakes."

"Wh-What? Really? . . . . .Now I feel like an idiot." He said, hanging his head.

"You should." You giggled. "Come on. I'm done here and I think we can make it back to my house by now." You said, grabbing his wrist and pulling him along.

You guys left out the door and snuck through the forest by hopping from tree to tree. Or more like Mask hopped from tree to tree while you had a piggy-back ride. Once he made it to the tree line he jumped down, unnoticed, and set you down.

"Masky, you should probably take off your mask. Trick-or-treat is already over and the police might be suspicious." You said looking at him worriedly. You weren't gonna let your boyfriend be put in jail just cause he had a mask on. He looked at you sadly, not wanting to take off his mask, but complied and took it off anyways.

You guys walked down the road for awhile and it was pretty quiet cept for your footsteps. Masky eventually gained the courage and reached over to hold your hand, making his and your face burn red, before you held his hand as well. You guys walked hand in hand the rest of the way to your house and your mom opened the door. You blushed darker and Masky quickly tried to put his mask on, somehow succeeding even with one hand. Your mom looked over him and then at you, after a moment she smiled.

"So _____, is this the boy you always talk about?"

"Y-Yeah mom. This is my uh *couch*boyfriend*cough* Masky." You had already told your mom you were dating a boy, but were still embarrassed to talk about him around her, especially now since it was the first time you had brought him over. Or well, more like the first time he came over when people were home besides you. Masky reached his free hand out and your mother shook it.

"Well come on in you two. _____ his surprise is all set up and in the fridge like you asked." You mom winked at you as you walked in.

"K thanks mom." You started walking with Masky to the kitchen as your mom put on her jacket.

"Well I have to go do some late-night shopping. I'll be back later _____." She said walking out the door.

"Ok, bye mom." You shut the door behind her then led Masky to the dining room, making him set down in a chair at the table.

"Now I'll be right back with your surprise Mask~" you said, skipping into the kitchen from the dinning room where you left him. He went ahead and took his mask off, sitting it on the tanble as he waited. You went and opened the fridge, smiling as you picked up his surprise and brought it to Masky.

"Here you go Masky~ My specialty for my special boyfriend~!" You said sitting down a cheesecake decorated with chocolate and other sweet things in front of Mask. He gasped and hugged you tight. Cheesecake was his absolute favorite!

"Thank you _____! I should've never gotten mad at you!" He said still hugging you tightly. You giggled and gave him a fork as he let go. He sat down and got a big bite on the fork before you took it from him and sat beside him.

"Heeey. That's miiiine." He whined, now kinda irritated. You smiled and held the fork toward his mouth.

"I'm gonna feed you~! Say 'Ahh' Masky~" He was fed up, irritated, and hungry for sweets stuff, so he did the only thing he could. He went along with it.

"Ahhh." He then chomped down on it with a smile, loving the sweet taste.

You giggled and got another bite for him, but he gave you a quick peck on the lips, making you freeze in place with a blush. He then smirked and took the fork, scarfing down the cheesecake quickly. Finally he got the sweet treat he had been wanting for weeks. And a little more sweets kisses afterwards.

THE END

~~~~~~~~~~

A/N: So that was my first CreepyPasta X Reader~! I hope you all enjoyed it!

Comments are appreciated~!

Preview pic made by ~IzayaAssassin, not me.